In its judgment of 26 June 2026 (II FSK 838/25), the Supreme Administrative Court (NSA) held that the CIT treatment of customer impersonation fraud may differ from ordinary non-payment: where the legitimate customer neither contracted nor received the goods, no revenue due arose in that case. The sales proceeds never received are still not a tax-deductible expense, and the ruling does not automatically cover ordinary non-payment for a validly completed sale.
Businesses selling on credit usually must recognise revenue even when the buyer does not pay, so the CIT treatment of customer impersonation fraud matters in practice, particularly in cross-border sales. The NSA has examined a case in which fraudsters posing as a legitimate customer obtained goods, and the tax authority has since followed its reasoning.
What happened in the case decided by the NSA?
A Polish manufacturer of refrigeration equipment received an order from a person claiming to be the commercial director of a French company and, after checking the customer’s registration details and VIES status, sent equipment worth PLN 87,527.85 (EUR 19,474) to a warehouse in France. After the payment deadline, the French company denied any contract or receipt, saying the signature and stamp were not its own and that it did not operate the warehouse. The supplier reported the fraud to law enforcement and asked the Director of the National Tax Information (KIS) whether it had to recognise revenue.
Why does fraud not necessarily create taxable revenue?
Under Article 12(3) of the CIT Act, revenue includes amounts due even if payment has not been received, so non-payment of a genuine sale generally does not remove the duty to recognise revenue. The decisive question is whether the supplier has an enforceable receivable arising from an actual sale.
The NSA found that the legitimate customer neither ordered nor received the goods, so the invoice did not document a genuine sale and the supplier had no claim for payment against the customer named on it. The judgment rested on Article 12(3) read with Article 12(3a), not on a general exclusion of transactions linked to criminal activity.
How did the authority and the courts rule?
On 7 June 2024 KIS ruled that the company should recognise revenue matching the invoice, with a possible later adjustment, and the Provincial Administrative Court in Kraków upheld this on 19 December 2024 (I SA/Kr 653/24). The NSA overturned both on 26 June 2026, rejecting recognition first and adjustment later. On 8 October 2026 KIS issued a new ruling confirming that no revenue had to be recognised, which applies to this case and is not a general interpretation covering every commercial fraud.
Can the lost goods be deducted, and what about VAT?
Lost sales proceeds cannot be deducted: revenue never earned is not an expense incurred to generate revenue and does not meet Article 15(1) of the CIT Act. The actual costs of purchasing or manufacturing the goods need a separate assessment, which the NSA did not comprehensively determine. VAT also requires its own analysis, since in judgment I FSK 1641/23 of 7 May 2026 the NSA found no taxable supply in that case, but CIT conclusions should not automatically be applied to VAT.
What documentation should a supplier keep?
An unpaid invoice alone does not show that no revenue arose. Useful evidence may include:
- Correspondence, purchase orders and the purported customer’s details.
- Due diligence records, such as VIES checks.
- Transport documents and a statement from the legitimate customer.
- Records of the fraud report.
The NSA did not make the absence of revenue due conditional on completing criminal proceedings, but ruling proceedings rely on the facts presented by the applicant, and the actual course of events may be verified in later tax proceedings.
Read the full article here: Goods fraud and CIT in Poland – when does a fraudulent transaction not generate taxable revenue?
SUCCESSFUL INVESTING IN POLAND – NEWSLETTER
Looking for new business opportunities in Poland? Get key updates on investments, the economy and market trends — straight to your inbox.
SUBSCRIBE TO THE NEWSLETTER

